To Each According to Their Need | Food & Solidarity Newcastle

To Each According to Their Need

A founding rule of Food & Solidarity, not a slogan.

Need Does Not Arrive Fully Formed

It emerges through struggle, through conversation, through people testing what is possible and naming what is missing. Often, it only becomes clear once people begin acting together.

Someone comes for food and talks about rent. Someone asks about a bailiff letter and ends up talking about damp, exhaustion, fear of opening the door. Someone joins to pack parcels and six months later is sitting in Newcastle County Court with a neighbour they met at a meeting.

What looks like one problem reveals another beneath it. The rule exists because of this.

How Institutions Respond

Institutions prefer fixed answers. They decide in advance what people are allowed to need, then build systems to deliver just that.

Anything outside the frame is treated as confusion, dishonesty, or failure. You needed food, not housing help. You needed housing help, not a vote on how the money is spent.

The Rule

At Food & Solidarity, "to each according to their need" is not a slogan. It is a founding rule of the organisation, written into how it works.

  • Every member pays a sliding scale fee: £3/month for unwaged workers, one hour's wage for higher earners
  • Every member receives the same: two food parcels a month, regardless of what they pay in
  • Every member has one vote
  • Every member can bring proposals to the collective
  • The funds belong to everyone

What you receive is determined by what you need, not by what you paid in.

From Support to Collective Action

As patterns become clearer, our response changes.

A member facing eviction is not a case to be managed. They are a member, with the same standing as every other member, which means the organisation moves with them. Grace went to Newcastle County Court with members beside her. Dennis trained for his eviction in Leazes Park. Breamish House residents delivered one collective letter and had repairs done in 24 hours.

What feels like a personal crisis is recognised as a shared condition.

Needs that appear separate are understood as connected, rent, food, debt, childcare, safety.

Working Through Contradictions

Not all needs can be met in the same way. Sometimes they pull in different directions. Sometimes resources are limited.

These tensions are real, and pretending otherwise helps no one.

The point is not to erase contradiction, but to work through it together.

When decisions are made collectively, priorities emerge from lived reality, not from theory or bureaucracy. We act, we learn from the results, and we return to the community with what we've learned, adjusting, correcting, sharpening our response.

Not Charity, Not Service Delivery

This is not charity and it is not service delivery.

It is a process.

What "To Each According to Their Need" Means

It means that a member who joined last week and a member who has been here since 2020 have the same vote at the same meeting. It means the person who receives a food parcel this month may be the person who sits in court with a neighbour next month. It means resources are held collectively and decisions are made collectively.

Need is dynamic, shaped by material conditions, and clarified through acting together.

What people need today may not be what they need tomorrow. The rule has to be flexible enough to move with that reality, and so does the organisation.

Solidarity Is Not a Fixed Answer

It is a method, tested, corrected, and rebuilt in common.

Join Food & Solidarity Newcastle

Pay what your situation allows. Receive what you need. Vote on decisions. Bring proposals. The funds are collective, and so is everything else.

Become a Member

Frequently Asked Questions

What does "to each according to their need" mean at Food & Solidarity?

It is a founding rule of the organisation. Every member pays a sliding scale membership fee, £3/month for unwaged workers, one hour's wage for higher earners. Every member receives the same: two food parcels a month, regardless of what they pay in. Every member has one vote. Every member can bring proposals to the collective. The funds belong to everyone. What you receive is determined by what you need, not by what you paid in.

How does the sliding scale membership work?

£3/month for unwaged workers. £4/month for part-time or precarious workers. £10/month for minimum waged workers. One hour's wage per month for higher earners. Regardless of what members pay in, every member receives the same food parcels, has the same vote, and can bring the same proposals to member meetings. Join →

Is Food & Solidarity a charity?

No. Food & Solidarity is a democratic, member-led, non-profit organisation. Members receive food parcels and decide collectively how funds are spent. There are no donors giving to recipients. Everyone pays in according to their means and receives according to their need. What we are →

Who can vote at Food & Solidarity?

Every member has one vote, regardless of how long they have been a member or how much they pay in. A member who joined last week and a member who has been here since 2020 have the same vote at the same meeting. Any member can bring proposals to the collective.